Why was Arsenal not awarded a penalty?

Why did Arsenal escape a penalty in the game against Newcastle? The disputed referee decision along with VAR’s involvement has been clarified by the Premier League.

Arsenal secured a dramatic 2-1 victory over Newcastle United at St. James’ Park, a ground where they have faced tough challenges for many years. It was the first time since 2023 that the “Gunners” left with all three points, thanks largely to defender Gabriel’s precise header in the 90+6th minute.

However, the Brazilian player’s journey to hero status was filled with difficulties. In the 34th minute, Gabriel was criticized for allowing Nick Woltemade to get past him during a corner, leading to Newcastle’s opening goal. The play highlighted his sluggishness and indecision, nearly making him the scapegoat.

More dramatically, just minutes before the winning goal, Gabriel slipped while trying to block Anthony Elanga inside the penalty area. The ball bounced off his shin and then hit his hand, causing the St. James’ Park crowd to roar for a penalty. VAR immediately reviewed the incident, and after thorough examination, referee Jarred Gillett confirmed no penalty, ruling that the ball touched the foot first. This controversial decision was pivotal, paving the way for Gabriel’s stoppage-time goal.

VAR intervened strongly more than once in the first half. Viktor Gyokeres took advantage of a Newcastle defensive error, broke through to face Nick Pope, and fell inside the box. The referee initially pointed to the penalty spot, but after reviewing the footage, Gillett reversed the decision, confirming that Newcastle’s goalkeeper had touched the ball in time.

In the end, Arsenal returned home with valuable 3 points, especially as their direct rival Liverpool unexpectedly lost to Crystal Palace. This win not only helps Mikel Arteta’s team stay in the title race but also demonstrates their never-give-up spirit despite nearly losing points due to Gabriel’s earlier mistake.

From “villain” to “hero,” Gabriel experienced an emotional 90 minutes, ultimately becoming the player who brought complete joy to Arsenal fans at the hostile St. James’ Park.